Press "Enter" to skip to content

Teacher pay tops list of Mathews budget concerns

The Mathews County School Board got an early start on this year’s budget process—and members quickly determined they’ll need every minute of that time in order to plead their case for increased compensation for teachers and support staff with county supervisors and the community at large.

Normally, the school board holds its first budget work session in January; this year, that work session was convened before the start of December’s regular monthly meeting, which was held on Tuesday in the Mathews High School media center.

While school board members were presented with a 122-item list of needs to consider, including capital projects and items requested by the division’s three principals, discussion focused primarily on one item—the need to boost pay in order to retain quality teachers and compete with neighboring school districts for an ever-shrinking pool of classroom instructors.

Even if the governor’s proposed 5 percent pay increase for Virginia teachers (to take effect July 1, 2019) makes it through the General Assembly, that raise will be experienced statewide and Mathews will still find itself lagging far behind other area school divisions.

“We’ve got to have a substantial increase,” said school board chairman John Priest. “I think it needs to be our top priority … (our) absolute top priority.”

Mathews County Public Schools has experienced salary increases in only five of the last 10 budget cycles, Superintendent of Schools Nancy Welch said, with an annual average increase over the last decade of 1 percent. Meanwhile, the federal Bureau of Labor Statistics’ cost of living adjustment over the same period equated to a 19.4 percent increase.

“We’re going backwards with their salary,” Welch said. Meanwhile, both Gloucester and Middlesex schools saw substantial increases in their salary scales last year. If Mathews hopes to be competitive with its two geographically closest school systems, she suggested that Mathews would need to have a salary increase on the order of at least 10 percent.

“Ideally,” the board should look at a 15 percent pay increase, said vice chairman Melissa Mason.

Mathews currently ranks 92nd out of 132 divisions statewide in terms of teacher compensation. In the region including the Middle Peninsula and Northern Neck, only Westmoreland County has a lower starting salary for a teacher with no experience and a bachelor’s degree ($39,276, compared to $39,000 for Westmoreland).

“We’re the bottom of the bottom,” Welch said.

Mathews has begun to feel the effects of the national teacher shortage, the superintendent said. Several teaching positions were only recently filled for the current year, including several that have provisional licenses.

“This is our reality now,” she said. “We do not get the applications. We are not competitive.”

If Mathews continues to slip in comparison to its neighbors, she added, “that list (of teachers hired late and lacking full credentials) is going to be double next year. I guarantee it.”

Each percentage point increase in compensation costs the county around $100,000 to $110,000, Welch said. And the governor’s proposal, if it were to win approval, only covers positions mandated by the state’s Standards of Quality, leaving the county to cover any increases in salary for support staff.

School board member Jeanice Sadler said that the school division must educate the county’s older, retired residents on the importance of investing in education, including more outreach to supervisors and the community.

“We’re going to have to reach out to them because they’re not coming to us,” Sadler said.

If the school system fails in its job of educating the county’s youth, school board member Linda Hodges said, the county will pay the price in terms of higher Social Services costs and jail fees as these students won’t have the skills necessary to compete in the workforce. “That is where there is a cost to our county,” said Hodges.

During the regular board meeting that followed, staff and the public were given the opportunity to address the board on the 2019-2020 budget. It was then that the issue of teacher compensation was given a face.

Mathews High School teacher Rachel Morris, representing the Mathews Education Association, held back tears as she spoke about the problems associated with Mathews neglecting its teacher salaries.

Hiring teachers who are still working on their credentials is something that would not be tolerated in other professions. “You don’t get a root canal from a dentist who’s still taking college classes,” Morris said. “You don’t want an EMT who can’t pass a CPR test.”

Losing teachers with years of experience and hiring a new college graduate is sometimes seen as a help to budgets, because of the lower starting salary. “That is such a terrifying idea,” she said. Mathews lost seven professionals to other schools in the past year, she said. Losing their knowledge and experience means that the school is constantly working to bring these new teachers up to speed, and students are paying the price, she said.

Morris related her own experience as a Mathews student. “I was a member of Dave Shuber’s band. If you live in Mathews, you know that’s a thing,” she said. At its height, the band had numbers approaching 90 students. A decade later, the band has 19 members, she said.

During her five years working in Mathews, she has seen four band and chorus teachers and two long-term substitutes. “As a fine arts department, we can’t grow,” she said.

“It’s time for our county to recognize this as a community problem,” Morris said. “We need you guys to lead the example,” she told the board members. “We need you to be bold.”

“It’s not a job, it’s a mission in this county … it always has been,” Thomas Hunter Middle School principal Laurel Byrd said of teaching. However, “we see that slipping away.” All three principals spoke of the difficulty of finding good quality applicants for teaching positions, something that was unheard of a decade ago.

If we do only one thing, Byrd said, we need to take care of our teachers and support staff. “They have got to feel this is worth it,” she said. She said that a message needs to be sent to the community that “they’re at a breaking point.”

Lee-Jackson Elementary teacher Christina Tomcany said that she is working as a waitress and coaching a local rowing team in order to make ends meet.

And while she conceded that other people are also having to work several jobs to get by, Tomcany said that she goes home worrying about a myriad of school issues, like whether a student has the snack pack he needs to get enough to eat at home. “They’re not having that internal dialog all the time,” she said of others who hold down several jobs.

After two years of also waitressing, she said, it is wearing on her. She said she saw a recent picture of her and her daughter and thought, “God, I look tired.” 

“I don’t want to move away. I want to pay taxes here … don’t push us away,” Tomcany said.

In the end, the school board decided to prepare an initial draft of its budget looking at several pay increases (5 percent, 10 percent, 15 percent and 20 percent). 

The school board will hold its next budget work session before its January meeting, at 4 p.m. on Tuesday, Jan. 15 in the MHS media center.