A recent audit of internal records kept by Mathews Clerk of Circuit Court Elizabeth Brown turned up some findings that the auditor determined could “lead to noncompliance with laws and regulations, the loss of assets or revenues, or otherwise compromise the clerk’s fiscal accountability.”
Lori Hicks, audit director for the Virginia Auditor of Public Accounts, said that such an audit typically turns up perhaps one or two findings that need to be addressed, but in this case, there were findings in seven areas.
“This is certainly not a good error rate,” said Hicks, pointing out that several of the findings were repeats from last year’s audit. She said that whether or not corrections have been made from one year to the next depends on “what’s behind the weakness.” Some things can be addressed relatively quickly, she said, while others could take longer.
“If they have to get somebody hired and trained up, it could take a while, especially with assessment and billing of court costs,” she said. “If a bookkeeper all of a sudden leaves, it could take a while to dig out … If they have turnover in a small office like this, it can be problematic to their functioning.”
The most serious finding, said Hicks, was that the clerk had not reconciled the bank account to the financial accounting system since March 2023.
The audit report states that “allowing reconciling items to go unresolved can lead to errors and irregularities going undetected and increase the risk of loss of funds.” The report stated that the clerk should immediately reconcile the bank account to the accounting system and continue to do so in a timely manner going forward.
The second most serious finding was that the clerk and her staff didn’t properly assess and bill court costs, which was the case in last year’s audit, as well. In a sampling of 26 cases, errors were found in half of them. This resulted in not charging defendants $7,896 in court costs. The impact was not projected to all transactions, said the report. Rather, the auditor said that the specific cases noted should be corrected and that staff needed more training in the assessment and billing of court costs.
The third most serious finding was that the clerk didn’t deposit funds and remit state collections in a timely fashion, a repeat finding from last year’s audit. Between October of 2024 and December of 2025, the office received checks totalling $6,172 that were not recorded or deposited, and the funds were not remitted to the state, said the report.
Fourth on the list was that the clerk didn’t properly monitor and disburse court liabilities for the second year in a row. At the end of the audit period, $138,096 was being held in liability accounts that should have either been paid or escheated, said the report. Hicks explained that these funds consist of such items as restitution payments, criminal bonds, and trust fund accounts. If the funds can’t be paid out for some reason, perhaps because the owner can’t be located, she said that the clerk needs to have them escheated and returned to the custody of the state.
The final three findings were not repeats from last year.
It was found that the clerk didn’t submit claims to the Virginia Department of Taxation for tax set-off refunds for delinquent court fines and costs totalling $2,831. Hicks explained that tax set-off refunds are debts assessed against tax refunds. If a person owes money to the state, the debt is paid by deducting the money from their tax refund. The clerk would have been notified that there were tax funds, said Hicks, but didn’t respond, so the refund went to the person instead.
Additionally, the clerk did not promptly resolve accounting errors, resulting in negative balances totalling $59,000 in the account codes for the court’s savings account, non-reverting funds, and state revenues. There were other errors, as well. Hicks said that negative balances are usually an accounting error. It’s the clerk’s responsibility to look at the ledger and fix any negative balances, she said, but this was not properly being done.
Finally, the annual trust fund report was not filed with the court for fiscal year 2025. Hicks said clerks sometimes miss the deadline for this report, and it’s typically written up in the audit, but it’s “probably the least egregious” of the findings.
Hicks said that the Virginia Compensation Board can refuse to give the clerk pay raises if there are findings in the audit report.
“That’s a good reason to clear them up,” she said.
The audit ends with a Sept. 20 letter in response from Brown. In that letter, she states, “The largest area where improvement is needed is consistency. For a variety of reasons, the office has experienced high rates of staff turnover and still has one empty position. Consistently and dependably following procedures has fallen short because of this.”
When reached on Tuesday for comment, Brown said that “unfortunately, errors were recognized in our audit report. While not what I want for the office, the audit process is appreciated to help correct deficiencies. The office continues to modify best practices and all staff will be participating in continued education to reinforce enhanced procedures.”
