Press "Enter" to skip to content

Letter: Does federal law trump state law?

Editor, Gazette-Journal:

Can a state pass and enforce a law that is in opposition to a federal law?

Those who think not cite what is called the Supremacy Clause, which they interpret to say that federal law is supreme over state law. Some would argue that the states cannot pick and choose which laws they wish to honor.

But, what exactly does the Supremacy Clause say? Article Six, Clause Two states: This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof … shall be the supreme law of the land.

Those who are unknowing—or are deliberately misleading—contend that this clause says that U.S. law trumps state law.

"Thereof" refers to the Constitution. Laws are to be made in pursuance to the Constitution. What about "shall be made in Pursuance" thereof? Pursuance means following or in keeping with. Thus, only those laws that are in keeping with the Constitution are supreme law of the land. And, those not in keeping with the C...

To view the rest of this article, you must log in. If you do not have an account with us, please subscribe here.