The public will have an additional seven weeks to comment on the U.S. Coast Guard’s proposal to downgrade Station Milford Haven to seasonal status after public outcry over the matter and the intervention of Rep. Rob Wittman (R-Montross).

John Hooper of Hartfield, a retired Coast Guardsman who has a sailboat at Stingray Point, was one of a number of area residents who spoke in opposition to the U.S. Coast Guard’s proposal to downgrade Station Milford Haven to seasonal status during a meeting at the Piankatank Ruritan Club in Mathews on Monday.
Wittman announced the time extension during a public meeting held jointly with the Coast Guard on Monday at the Piankatank Ruritan Club in Mathews. Over 100 people attended the meeting, which was announced just last Wednesday. The Congressman pulled the event together quickly, after learning of the proposal last month, in order to meet Tuesday’s original deadline for comment.
Capt. Jennifer Stockwell, Deputy Commander of Sector Virginia, USCG, gave brief comments at the meeting, but said she was primarily there to listen to what the public had to say. She was accompanied by Lt. Cmdr. Katherine Blue, public affairs officer for the Mid-Atlantic Region; Michael Voss, director of External Affairs and Government Relations for Headquarters Fifth District; and BMC Joshua Menges, Chief at Station Milford Haven.
Prior to the meeting, Stockwell said that the downgrade was a proposal that had not yet been finalized and that comments from the meeting would be taken into consideration, along with comments made in the Federal Register.
In evaluating whether to close the station on a seasonal basis, Stockwell said the Coast Guard had “looked into redundancies in the area and thought there was a need to find efficiencies.” She emphasized that U.S. Coast Guard stations, patrol boats and air stations were the assets that were considered, and that state and local assets that might be able to respond to incidents were not part of the decision.
“We see local assets as supplementing our obligations,” she said.
She also emphasized that it was not a political decision, but that it was made “looking at our operational capabilities.”
“Stations Indigo, Crisfield, Wachapreague, Cape Charles, and Portsmouth are all within 50 miles,” she said. “It’s hard to say exactly how long response times are, but our fast response boats are capable of going 40 knots (about 46 mph).”
During her opening remarks, Stockwell said that she realized that the flow of information regarding the proposed downgrade “would have and should have been better.” While the Coast Guard published notice in the Federal Register about the intended closure of several stations, which it termed “Consolidation of Redundant Coast Guard Boat Stations,” no notice was published on the proposed downgrade of Milford Haven. According to Wittman, Milford Haven is the only station nationwide that’s being proposed for downgrade.
Stockwell said the downgrade, if finalized, will allow the Coast Guard to “pool assets, personnel, and resources.” She said improved technologies have reduced notification times, including the ability to quickly notify local agencies, and that the Coast Guard now has “robust location abilities” and can “respond with overlapping asset coverage.”
While Memorial Day to Labor Day is the typical time for a seasonal station to be open, said Stockwell, that time can be adjusted “if boating activity warrants.” She said she would relay the concerns expressed during the meeting to headquarters.
Wittman said that the idea of a seasonal closure “is problematic because the other stations are on the other side of the bay.”
“When the water temperature is below 50 degrees, your time to survive is extraordinarily short,” he said.
While the Coast Guard based its decision on a reduction in rescue requests between 2014 and 2019, he said, the record high of purchases of watercraft in 2020 and 2021 was not reflected in the data.
“The water is our lifeblood,” said Wittman. “The Coast Guard’s presence here is as important if not more important than anyplace else in the United States. This is the presence of our federal government.”
During public comment period, a number of people spoke.
Melanie Procopio of Cobbs Creek expressed concerns about drug interdiction. Having so much tidal shoreline in the region provides an opportunity for drug traffickers to bring drugs into the area, she said.
Stockwell responded that such comments would be instrumental in the Coast Guard’s decision, since Coast Guard stations don’t just provide search and rescue but have multiple missions.
Mathews County’s new Interim County Administrator Sandy Wanner said that local waterways are used year-around, not just seasonally, and that recreational boaters, fishermen, hunters and watermen are all among those who rely on Station Milford Haven.
One Cobbs Creek resident said that the federal Department of Homeland Security’s valuation of a statistical human life, as used to evaluate the efficacy of risk reduction strategies, is $11.6 million. He said the 47 cases worked by Station Milford Haven last year would have statistically resulted in 10 to 12 lives saved, at a risk reduction of at least $116 million.
“I can’t imagine $116 million in savings from a seasonal closure,” he said.
He also pointed out that the Coast Guard couldn’t “invoke closure” without public notification.
John Hooper of Hartfield, a retired Coast Guardsman who has a sailboat at Stingray Point, said this year had probably been one of the busiest on the Chesapeake Bay. He said a lot of watermen are on the bay throughout the winter to make a living and that “huge merchant ships” continually sail up and down the bay to Maryland. He raised the specter of such a ship running aground or being involved in a collision and leaking oil.
“It will need immediate response,” he said.
Ray Procopio of Cobbs Creek said around half of the 200 or so households along Queens Creek own a power craft of some sort, and that there’s a commercial marina with 40 boats there, as well. He said he had been out on the water in the middle of winter and had seen over 100 boats fishing in the middle of the day. He said there’s been an increase in paddle craft in the area, and that statistics show those craft are involved in more than half of fatal accidents on the water.
“There’s a critical need for a Coast Guard presence and quick response,” he said. “We’re all concerned about the response time from Portsmouth to Mathews, but what if it’s 20 miles up the bay?”
Middlesex County supervisor John Koontz said that the county has 10,000 residents, but 30,000 boaters who come to his county every year.
“Our whole county economy is driven by boating,” he said, adding that those people needed to feel secure. He turned in a petition that he said contained 200 signatures, gathered in the small amount of time since he had learned about the proposed closure.
Robin Wells of Deltaville said if the station closes, the local sheriff’s office will have to “pick up the load,” which will have a budget impact on the county.
“The Coast Guard has the best trained people in the world at what they do,” he said. “It’s not an insult to the sheriff’s office, but they don’t have the training.”
Harry Sadler of Hanover, who served in the auxiliary at Milford Haven after retiring from the Coast Guard, said the station has one of the biggest coverage areas in the Coast Guard.
“I don’t think the other stations can cover it,” he said. “Two hours could be life or death.”
He questioned the cost for shutting down and reopening the station every year, asking whether it would be staffed by reservists who are paid a per diem.
Dave Jones of Mathews, a former Coast Guardsman, said that a seasonal closure would cause personnel to have to “change billets at a crazy rate,” with personnel constantly having to get used to the waterways and the people.
Several speakers, including George Manseur, expressed concern that local volunteer agencies don’t have the training that the Coast Guard has to conduct missions on the water.
Gordon White, chairman of the Middlesex Economic Development Authority, questioned whether the Coast Guard would increase personnel at its other stations because of the increased travel time it would take to respond to the Middle Peninsula, and Stockwell said that more crew would be added.
Jack White of New Point said that the annual Mathews Rotary Rockfish Tournament brings in over 100 boats on a Saturday, that there had been a dilution of safe passageways in Mathews because of the lack of dredging, and that there had been an increase in the number of small boats and kayaks.
“We need more Coast Guard, not less,” he said.
Karyn Austin of Mathews questioned the lack of available information on the underlying data that the Coast Guard used in its study. She said she had found information in the Journal of the Coast Guard that argued that more assistance is needed, not less, because the needs of industry are growing at such a fast pace. She pointed out the Homeland Security missions of the Coast Guard, including counter-terrorism and surveillance, and said the Milford Haven downgrade would “make another void.”
“How can you assure the same level of response time and safety when it’s physically impossible to reach?” Austin said.
Bobby Dobson of Cobbs Creek questioned whether there would be any savings in downgrading the station, since the personnel there will just be relocated and the boats and the buildings will still need maintenance.
Among others who spoke were Mike Walls of Hudgins, Tyrone Hudgins of Grimstead, Jackie Wilton of Cobbs Creek, Dee Russell of Hudgins, Will Miller (address unknown), Craig Lewis of Port Haywood, Sharon Frye of Mathews, and Mathews Christmas Store director and real estate agent Bernadette La Casse.
Wittman said there had been no real articulation of why the Coast Guard wants to downgrade Milford Haven. When he asked about cost savings, operational streamlining, and how many billets would be saved, he said the answer was none. He said his office would find the studies underlying the decision and put them on his website, https://wittman.house.gov.
Cmdr. Blue said that anyone with objections to the proposed downgrade may make their objections known by visiting regulations.gov and typing in “Consolidation of Redundant Coast Guard Boat Stations.” However, at present, it still stated on the site that the deadline was Aug. 3.
The proposal itself is available at www.federalregister.gov/documents/2021/06/09/2021-12105/consolidation-of-redundant-coast-guard-boat-stations.

